Wellness Grain-Free Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Herring

I have been ordering this food for almost two years on a monthly basis and my cats love it. The problem is that this month the price jumped from $47 to $66 WHICH IS INSANE. What happened??

Great food, my cat eat it constantly. It has always been a well known brand.

I have been feeding my cats Wellness Food for four years now.

What I like most is that, like most of the Wellness line, this Chicken and Herring blend is made without grains. Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they only need meat…in the wild they only get grains in the stomach of prey they eat. If you put grains in food, cats continue to eat until they’ve had enough protein. So the grain is just added calories for nothing. Since grains are cheaper per ounce, it’s a great way to save the manufacturer money, but it’s not good for your cats.

In the first year after switching from dried food and lower-quality grain-filled wet food, both my cats lost weight and their fur became softer and shinier. The difference was most evident in my plump, dumb inactive cat; he lost a couple of pounds and went from middle-aged dumpy to sleek and active. He has gotten a lot smarter and is more lively in general.

I also like that this food doesn’t have any rendered animal fat or meat byproducts, which are disgusting slaughterhouse waste it is illegal to sell to humans.

As far as how my cats feel, they think this is just okay. They would give it three stars for the smell/taste. They always prefer the cheap stuff, like fancy feast, because it is swimming in rendered fat which smells delicious to cats just like potato chips do to humans. I call it “kitty crack.” Cats choose food mainly on smell, not taste, which works great in the wild but not so much with commercial foods where their quality sensor is way off. To get my cats to eat this food at first, I needed to mix it with kitty crack–first only a quarter good to 3/4 kitty crack and gradually building up to 100% over about six months. It’s never a good idea to get into a battle of will with cats…first of all, you’ll lose, and second it is not safe for them to go more than 24 hours without food because of potentially fatal liver issues.

After the initial break-in period, my cats ate this happily. This is the favorite of both my cats, followed by Turkey/Salmon blend as second favorite. I buy a variety to mix it up nutritionally and to make sure they don’t get too fussy. Since they never overeat this, I simply feed them as much as they want…if they ask for more, I give it.

One can is enough to feed one cat per day. This size must be opened with a can opener and stored in between uses. For this reason not as convenient as the 5.5 ounce sizes which you just pull open, but the cost difference over a year is substantial. It’s not too much of a pain as on days that aren’t too hot I leave this on the counter at room temperature between feedings. If for any reason it’s not done by bedtime I put it in the fridge. Cat’s digestion is much faster and a bit of bacteria in food is less likely to cause problems.

Cost-wise, these are about $2 a day, and Amazon’s price is competitive with big-box pet food stores. When I first started using this, the price seemed prohibitive so I took out the calculator and did a serious analysis. Compared with the Fancy Feast I was buying at a big-box store, per ounce this is a LOT more expensive. But then I realized that since Fancy Feast is packed with grains and junk cats don’t need, comparing price by weight isn’t fair. I redid the analysis based on daily servings of protein, calories etc. and the two foods turned out identical in cost. It would still be cheaper to feed dried food but if I’m going to go 100% wet the price of this is actually comparable to supermarket foods.

Wellness also sells a Core brand which is even higher quality, but it doesn’t come in the larger more economical cans, making it prohibitively expensive.

Note: I read the one star reviews from here. Looks like there have been some quality-control issues with a new plant. I have not experienced this issue…the quality appears the same in the 4+ years I’ve been buying this. However, I will post if I experience a problem and update my review immediately.

Great food with great ingredients. My cats are picky eaters so we tried a few different flavors that we purchased locally first and settled on two. The only issue I have is with packaging as several of the cans come dented. So far, we’ve been able to open every can, so no big deal… so far. Other than that, would definitely recommend someone to try out a few flavors first before purchasing so many at this price. (Still better than local prices, but not if your cat doesn’t like it!)

This is the only brand we use with our cats. They are healthy, silky, shiny, and are an appropriate weight for their size. Since switching to this brand pate, to which we add a little water to increase their water consumption, no more stones! We give them each 2 TBSP of the Wellness dry just for something crunchy for their teeth in the morning but otherwise have moved away from dry food for their urinary health and to manage their weight. Two cats eat a half can per day for dinner. The vet recommended against even switching flavors saying that animals need to consistently eat the same brand and flavor for optimal results. Switching flavors can create gastro-issues. They have been on this flavor and brand for 5 years with great results! I highly recommend this cat food.